NetSquared enables social benefit organizations to leverage the tools of the social web.

Hot Spot

Want a N2Y3 recap?

View attendee blogs, vlogs and comments at Be NetSquared. Watch our NetSquared channel on Fora.tv

Congratulations to the N2Y3 Winners, in order: Ushahidi, KnowMore.org and Social Actions! Continue to show your support for all 21 Featured Projects. Watch conference sessions on Fora.tv's NetSquared Channel.

  • Home
  • Open Source, Open Standards Video

Open Source, Open Standards Video

Comments

Built on open (not free) standards?

You write: "Our platform is open-source and built on open-standards. This matters because it keeps video flowing freely. When you lock people in to closed, proprietary services, you lose everything that makes the Internet work."

Your proposal does not contain a single word about patents or free audio/video codecs/formats, and your website advertises playback of formats that are clearly neither open nor free (f you could send me the specs for the various windows media audio/video codecs, that'd be great, thanks, and the same for Sorensen which is often found in Quicktime).

The decision not even to try and promote free and open formats is disappointing and doesn't really justify the grand rhetoric you're employing IMHO.

 

 

One the point about open standards

I am not connected with the Democracy Player project, but my understanding of its build is that it uses Video LAN player as the backend to play all its videos.  Video LAN player supports nearly every video format and is itself an Open Source program.

Just because it can be played, doesn't mean it's open or free

Just because something can be played back by an open source player, doesn't mean the format is open. A lot of formats can only be played back by loading a Windows .dll binary that does the decoding like a black box (which will only work on x86) - the fact that the binary loader is open source doesn't change a bit the fact that the format being decoded isn't open and is also patent encumbered. The ffmpeg project (which vlc and xine and most other linux media players use for a lot of formats) does a great job at reverse-engineering codecs, documenting them and writing open source code for it, but even then the problem still remains that at least in most parts of the Americas and Europe Joe Linux User can't _legally_ use these because of patents. Similarly, anyone who sets up a website that makes use of these open source decoders or encoders risks being sued by the patent holders/license distributors for the formats involved. This is a great financial and personal risk to take (see recent Microsoft/mp3 debacle). As long as this is the case, there can't be any meaningful 'freedom' for content providers, producers or consumers (IMHO, of course). Not everyone will share this point of view, but I think it's at least something that warrants mention in a proposal/project like this.

Codec and Format Patents

I voted for this project. Some time ago I downloaded the Democracy Player, but so far I don't get into internet video much at all. Still, I support having an open source player and other video tools.

As for proprietary formats, etc., there is anoher commercial venture that goes about providing a video service where one can upload a video in most any format and the service goes about generating clones of it in all the various formats out there, and the end user can choose which format they prefer to view it in.

As for licesning, I'm sure that this project can pursue proper licensing, and if they're turned down for some particular format, there'll probably be another format that'll work on the user's system. Perhaps this project might be able to provide for converting proprietary formated materials to a non-proprietary format for distribution. Seems like a winner to me! Unless you actually like watching commercials in front of your video downloads...

Peopleunit

 

i voted for this

this was my top choice.

This is one of my top 7

This is one of my top 7 proposals. Good luck!

Top Project

This is definitely a top project!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Host

Cisco

User login

Subscribe to Net2News

Sign up for NetSquared's e-newsletter


Sitemap

About

Share

Projects

Conferences

Partner